page contents

Court live-streaming may very well be abused, says CJI

Attorney General Venugopal had pushed for it, saying everybody can then watch the court docket

Attorney General of India Okay.Okay. Venugopal on Monday pushed for live-streaming court docket proceedings to make hearings accessible to all.

But Chief Justice of India Sharad A. Bobde, heading a three-judge Bench of the Supreme Court, sounded a cautionary notice, saying it was inclined to “abuses.”

The trade got here on a day when the Gujarat High Court live-streamed its court docket hearings. “Live-streaming should be something on My Lords’ minds… Everyone can then watch the court,” the Attorney General submitted.

Mr. Venugopal reminded the Supreme Court of its personal judgment of September 2018 in favour of “opening up” the apex court docket by means of live-streaming. The judgment has remained unimplemented. Mr. Venugopal hinted that the pandemic provided a recent alternative.

“There are problems which should not be discussed publicly… There are certain abuses… We will take a decision soon enough, otherwise successive Chief Justices [turning to Justice D.Y. Chandrachud who is in line to be CJI] will do,” stated Chief Justice Bobde.

Open court docket system

Justice Chandrachud was one of many three judges on the Bench that gave the decision on live-streaming in September 2018. In truth, he had famous in his separate opinion that live-streaming of proceedings can be the true realisation of the “open court system.” Mr. Venugopal had assisted that Bench as amicus curiae. His strategies have been later adopted as tips within the September 2018 judgment.

The subject of live-streaming got here up as a Special Bench led by the CJI was taking inventory of the digital court docket system initiated quickly after the pandemic lockdown. Chief Justice Bobde stated the courts required entry to the fibre optic community to make sure higher connectivity even within the remotest components of the nation. The Chief Justice stated the north-eastern components may very well be related by way of satellite tv for pc.

At this level, senior advocate Harish Salve got here on to counsel the Jio community.

“HCs can frame rules”

Justice Chandrachud, on the Bench together with Justice L. Nageswara Rao, stated every excessive court docket could make its personal guidelines itself and trial courts underneath it for the digital court docket system. Uniform guidelines for all excessive courts would show troublesome, contemplating the distinction in connectivity and e-literacy.

On April 6, the Supreme Court had upheld the digital court docket system and deemed all restrictions imposed on individuals from coming into, attending or participating in court docket hearings as lawful within the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic.

Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *
%d bloggers like this: